Europe is changing course on migration. In Dublin, on 12 November 2026, 41 leaders endorsed a joint declaration to strengthen border controls, combat smuggling networks and accelerate the return of people with no right to remain. But behind this drive for firmness, European divisions persist. And one mechanism is now crystallising tensions: “return hubs,” centres envisaged in countries outside the European Union to which certain migrants subject to a removal decision would be transferred.
A divided Europe on the means
Giorgia Meloni’s Italy and Mette Frederiksen’s Denmark are among the leading advocates of a tougher approach. Friedrich Merz’s Germany, Donald Tusk’s Poland and Bart De Wever’s Belgium also support a reinforced approach to border controls and returns.
But their interests are not identical. Italy, faced with arrivals across the Mediterranean, is seeking to outsource part of migration management. Germany must balance border control with its economy’s needs. Poland also places the security of its eastern borders at the centre of its concerns.

The Afriques newsletter
- Free & no spam
- 1 email per day
- Unsubscribe in 1 click
Conversely, France, Spain and Luxembourg did not sign the Dublin declaration. Paris contests in particular the return centres in third countries. Madrid favours regularisation and professional integration, while continuing to face migratory pressure on the Canary Islands.
This divide reveals a major difficulty: who should welcome, who should control, and who should bear the financial and political consequences of migration?
Return hubs: practical solution or outsourcing of responsibilities?
The principle is straightforward: transfer to a country outside the EU individuals who have received a return decision, in order to organise their removal to their country of origin.
On 1 October 2026, the EU Council definitively adopted new rules opening up this possibility, subject to agreements with partner countries and respect for fundamental guarantees.
The Italian experience in Albania has nonetheless shown the difficulties of this model: legal challenges, significant costs and operational obstacles.
The debate takes on a new dimension with the Rwanda centre project presented on 16 November by Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands.
For their advocates, these mechanisms could make removal decisions more effective and discourage irregular stays. For their opponents, they risk shifting European responsibilities onto third countries without sufficiently guaranteeing the rights of the individuals concerned.
Africa facing the new balance of power
Morocco, Tunisia, Mauritania and the Sahel countries find themselves at the heart of this geopolitical reshaping. Europe needs their cooperation to control migration routes and facilitate readmissions. But these countries also have their own interests: economic development, investment, the mobility of their citizens and youth employment.
Can African states be asked to play a greater role in European migration policy without being offered a balanced economic and diplomatic partnership?
A societal question, not just a matter of borders
The European paradox remains: governments want to reduce arrivals while several economic sectors lack workers. At the same time, concerns about housing, employment, security and public services are fuelling social tensions and the rise of nationalist movements.
The right to asylum, the principle of non-refoulement and the individual examination of situations cannot, however, be set aside in the name of expulsion efficiency.
Can Europe outsource its borders without outsourcing its responsibilities? Will return hubs be a genuine instrument of migration control or the symbol of a Europe seeking to push the problem away rather than resolve it? The debate is open.
Documentary references
- British Government — Joint leaders’ statement on migration (European Political Community Summit, Dublin), 13 November 2026.
- Council of the European Union — New rules on the return of irregularly staying third-country nationals, 1 October 2026.
- OECD — International Migration Outlook 2026.
- Euronews — The practical and financial limits of return hubs.
- Joint statement by 47 organisations against the Rwanda hub project, 16 November 2026.















